Common Mistakes New Pet Owners Make with Dogs or Cats - And How to Avoid Them!

Jan 02, 2026Team Plato
A guide for new pet owners to avoid common mistakes with dogs or cats

Welcoming a new pet into your home is one of the most exciting experiences. However, it can also be overwhelming for new pet owners. From figuring out the right food to understanding your pet’s needs, there are plenty of challenges along the way. Many pet owners make common mistakes when bringing their furry companions home for the first time. In this blog, we’ll take a look at some of these mistakes and offer practical advice on how to avoid them, ensuring your new dog or cat is happy, healthy, and well-adjusted.

Being a responsible pet owner is a big task, but with the right knowledge and a little preparation, it becomes an enjoyable journey. Let’s dive into some of the most common mistakes new pet owners make with dogs or cats and explore how you can steer clear of them.

1. Not Preparing Your Home Properly

One of the first mistakes new pet owners make is not fully preparing their home for their new arrival. Whether you're adopting a puppy, kitten, or an older dog or cat, you need to create a safe and welcoming environment. This includes removing any hazards, setting up a designated sleeping area, and securing things like electrical cords and cleaning supplies that could pose a risk to your pet.

Additionally, make sure your pet has all the essentials, such as a bed, water and food bowls, and appropriate toys to keep them entertained. You can also give your pet a little extra luxury with our Chicken with Goat Milk & Collagen Food Topper to make mealtime even more exciting for your new furry friend.

2. Overfeeding or Underfeeding Your Pet

Another common mistake is not knowing how much to feed your pet. Overfeeding can lead to obesity, while underfeeding can leave your pet malnourished and lethargic. It’s important to follow the feeding guidelines based on your pet’s age, weight, and activity level.

If you’re unsure, consult your vet for advice on how to manage your pet’s diet. For a great food topper to ensure your pet gets the nutrition they need, try our Venison, Lamb & Collagen Food Topper. It’s packed with the right nutrients to boost your pet’s health and satisfy their taste buds.

3. Not Training or Socializing Your Pet Early Enough

Training is essential for your dog or cat to understand the rules of the house and learn how to behave in social situations. Many new pet owners think their pet will just “figure it out,” but training is key to ensuring your pet doesn’t develop bad habits like excessive barking or inappropriate scratching.

Start training early and be consistent with your commands. Reward-based training can also make it more fun for both of you. And remember, for some extra motivation during training sessions, check out our Small Bites With Lamb treats, perfect for rewarding good behavior!

4. Ignoring Your Pet’s Health Needs

Taking care of your pet’s health is one of the most important parts of ownership. Regular vet visits are crucial to ensure your pet is up-to-date on vaccinations and preventative care, such as flea and tick treatments. Additionally, monitor your pet for signs of illness, and don't hesitate to call your vet if something seems off.

It’s also important to provide a diet that promotes long-term health. Treat your pet to the benefits of healthy food with our Fish & Collagen Food Topper, packed with omega-3 fatty acids for a shiny coat and healthy skin.

5. Not Giving Your Pet Enough Mental Stimulation

Pets, especially dogs, need more than just physical exercise—they also need mental stimulation. Puzzle toys, interactive games, and teaching your pet new tricks can keep their brains active. Without this, your pet may get bored and start to engage in destructive behaviors.

For cats, try providing them with toys that mimic prey, or treat them to our Chicken & Catnip Cat Treats, which are sure to entertain and engage your feline friend.

6. Neglecting to Establish a Routine

Pets thrive on routine. Establishing regular feeding times, walks, and play sessions helps your pet feel secure and understand what to expect each day. A predictable schedule also helps with housebreaking and training.

If you're trying to get your new dog to settle in, don’t forget the importance of treats during training. Our Small Bites With Salmon are a great way to reward your dog while reinforcing good behavior.

7. Forgetting About Your Pet’s Emotional Wellbeing

Lastly, don’t forget that your pet has emotional needs. Bond with your new furry friend by spending quality time together, playing, and cuddling. Separation anxiety is common in pets, especially during the first few weeks after adoption. If your pet seems stressed, consider providing a comforting toy or blanket to help them feel secure.

If you’re looking for ways to help your pet feel more comfortable, try our Celebration Gift Box for a variety of treats that will make your pet feel special.

Conclusion

Becoming a pet owner is an incredible journey filled with love and joy. By avoiding these common mistakes, you can help ensure your dog or cat has a happy, healthy, and fulfilling life. Remember, pets rely on us to be their caregivers, so take the time to learn about their needs and make sure you're providing the best for them every day.

More Posts

Dog eagerly waiting for a high value dog treat during training
Jan 02, 2026
Ever notice how your dog suddenly turns into a laser-focused genius the moment a really...
Oriental Shorthair cat with oversized satellite-dish ears sitting alert and curious
Jan 03, 2026
Ever notice how some cats seem to hear a treat bag open from three rooms...